Maybe the government should just answer the questions

This approach in the Commons' Question Period really is childish--and wrong-headed since it makes people wonder why there are no substantive responses; amazing to have one's sympathy with the NDP:

NDP defence critic Dawn Black says Defence Minister Peter MacKay is being disrespectful and insulting by refusing to answer her party’s questions about the military.

In the House of Commons on Thursday, Mr. MacKay twice answered NDP queries by attacking the party rather than addressing the questions, and Ms. Black says that’s not right...

Ms. Black had asked a question about media reports that the air force is facing a $500-million funding shortfall because of spending on the Afghan mission.

Mr. MacKay retorted by pointing out that the NDP voted against the Afghan mission.

"Being a defence critic for the NDP is a bit like being a tailor in a nudist colony," he said. "There is lots to see, lots to talk about, but at the end of the day, they do not do anything. That is the naked truth about the NDP."

Later, NDP MP Catherine Bell asked Mr. MacKay when the government will replace outdated Buffalo search and rescue aircraft.

Mr. MacKay said it is cynical and hypocritical for the NDP to suggest it is "worried about the health and welfare and well-being of the Canadian Forces," as the party in the "communist corner" has voted against Tory legislation.

Ms. Black said it’s a "ridiculous slur" to call New Democrats communists.

"I just think it’s appalling," she said. "The lack of respect, the lack of dignity that he brings to that place over and over again."..