Wednesday, June 06, 2007

Liberals do support the troops

It's fine after all for the Canadian Forces to stay in Afghanistan--just as long as they don't have to fight. Which prompts the question: on what grounds (other than political) do the Liberals decide how much combat is enough? We know the NDP thinks no combat is what good soldiering is all about.
Liberal Leader Stéphane Dion yesterday opened the door to keeping Canadian troops in Afghanistan after February, 2009, but insisted they would have to be withdrawn from their current combat mission in the volatile southern region.

Speaking to reporters, Mr. Dion said he wants the combat mission of Canada's 2,500 soldiers based in Kandahar to end, but said Canada could still retain troops to assist the NATO mission...

The Liberals have been adamant in saying that Canada should advise NATO that it will be ending its military commitment in Afghanistan in early 2009 and pulling out its troops. But in recent weeks, the Liberals have been expressing a more nuanced [emphasis added] view, saying that they would be willing to support a scaled-back military presence, provided Canadian troops were redeployed to less dangerous parts of the country.

They have begun to talk about "rotation" among the NATO troops, implying that they would not be opposed to the Canadian troops switching places with soldiers from another coalition partner...

Defence critic Denis Coderre... insisted that the Canadians should be removed from the line of fire.

"The troops have done their job in the south," Mr. Coderre said. "We're done in terms of combat."..

3 Comments:

Blogger Algy said...

If any of these muppets had been around 63 years ago today I wonder if the history books would show a statement like -

"Although we realize that Canadians have been given - and accepted - responsibility for the landings on Juno Beach, we are against the notion of Canadians engaging in combat operations. Our forces have carried more than their fair share of the burden of this war since 1939, and it is time for Canadians to be removed from the line of fire. While we remain fully committed to the aims of the Allied Powers we believe that multilateral talks with Nazi Germany will provide a more nuanced solution and enable us to end hostilities.
"Canadians have done their job in the Far East, Italy, The Battle of the Atlantic, the skies over Europe, and now on the beaches of France", Mr Coderre said. "We're done in terms of combat.""

My wife's uncle Private Lloyd Kenneth Boswell, Cameron Highlanders of Ottawa (MG),landed on Juno Beach 63 years ago today. He was badly wounded outside of Caen on July 9th 1944 and died on July 15th. He is buried in the Commonwealth War Cemetery in Bayeux. Today,just as in the past, there are Canadians successfully engaging and defeating a brutal enemy and it is these Canadians I am proud of, not milque-toast politicians looking to score cheap points by denigrating the successes of our military.

11:16 a.m., June 06, 2007  
Blogger Babbling Brooks said...

Well said, Algy.

11:19 a.m., June 06, 2007  
Blogger Mark, Ottawa said...

algy: Check the link at "have been expressing a more nuanced"--great minds...

Mark
Ottawa

11:25 a.m., June 06, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home