Monday, December 22, 2008

The fighting left

From a post by Terry Glavin:

What Effective Progressive Activism Really Looks Like

A glimpse, in today's Globe and Mail, from a profile of our pal Lauryn Oates, co-founder of the Canada-Afghanistan Solidarity Committee.

Contrary to naysayers, Ms. Oates said, ordinary Afghans want international aid and intervention. "People have this incredible resilience," she said. "If they're willing to go on, we have to be behind them. The least we can do is stand by them. This is not about charity or pity."

For the opposite of progressive politics (the kind that animates the "anti-war left" in Canada today) and which our friends over at Shiraz Socialist have properly characterized as "a piece of propaganda for a fascist movement that would have been shocking six or seven years back, but wouldn’t raise an eyebrow now," you can read a thorough whitewash of the Taliban, if you can bear it, in International Socialism. Better to just read Shiraz, so you won't feel soiled...
Update: Mr Glavin has drawn this well-reasoned article in the straight.com to my attention--note the authors:
Canadian soldiers aren't dying for nothing in Afghanistan
...
Sverre Frisch studies political science at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver. He spent five years as an officer with the Norwegian Army, including two tours as a peacekeeper in the Balkans. Tylere Couture is a captain with the Canadian Forces and recently returned from a seven-month tour in Afghanistan with the Kandahar Provincial Reconstruction Team in Kandahar City. Couture and Frisch are both members of the UBC chapter of the Canada-Afghanistan Solidarity Committee.

3 Comments:

Blogger Dirk Buchholz said...

On the well reasoned article you mention I notice you do not (ever) talk about/link to, military families that basically say the same thing,i.e that their kids are dying in vain.
Indeed many of them put it this way ,....to supporters of the war ,...if you feel the Afghan war is worthy of death,sign up and encourage your own son's and daughter's to sign up ,in short unless you are willing to put your life on the line shut the hell up.
Good intentions are all well & good, but pray tell when will the government of Afghanistan be expected stand up,and do more than loot aid monies and profit from the misery of their own people.
Any way you cut it in the end, Afghans are the ones who must learn to live with one another,and until they stand up and point the way forward NATO might as well piss in the wind.
The West is not going to save the Afghans from themselves nor isolate/protect them from the regional & local contradictions that are at the root of the problem(s).

5:04 p.m., December 23, 2008  
Blogger Mark, Ottawa said...

Dirk Buchholz: I guess that, since Terry Glavin deletes all your comments, you're seeking new pastures upon which to defecate.

Mark
Ottawa

5:21 p.m., December 23, 2008  
Blogger Dirk Buchholz said...

What are you taking about,"defecate" ?
How,by pointing out,that even military families are speaking out and questioning the death's of their loved one.
In my books,their point of view is a hell of a lot more relevant than a couple of UBC students,and should be acknowledge.There are two sides to this story,are there not?
Forget me(I don't care if you like me),deal with concerns of the military families,that's my point.
As for Terry deleting me,please like I care.The same Terry who contacted me out of the blue expressing his admiration for my blog(it wasn't the other way around)? The same Terry who told me how Galloway "had him in stitches" that time he(Galloway) appeared before the senate committee.
You tell me what's changed ? Besides Terry deletes anyone who dare to question his judgment,i.e Dr Dawg etc etc,so be it.I "care".
But hey it's your blog,but at least tell me what you find so offensive about my comment or indeed my point of view.I mean you do not even know me,what's with the hostility ? I like to think I am a pretty laid back kind of person and one open to being swayed by the facts.
Anyway what more can I say ? Delete me,do what you gotta do.

2:42 a.m., December 24, 2008  

Post a Comment

<< Home