Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Germans and Italians in Afstan

Posts by BruceR at Flit:

1) Germans:

Mentoring in Mazar

Good piece on German army efforts in Der Spiegel:

Now it's Major Dietmar M.'s turn. He is a senior mentor, meaning he trains soldiers in the Afghan national army. At Camp Mike Spann, his charges show the visitors what they have learned, which includes repairing cars in accordance with German standards, maintaining weapons and caring for the wounded. The major talks about how difficult it is to build trust.

It is a good sign, he says, when one of his Afghan partners begins taking hold of both hands in greeting, instead of simply shaking hands. It is an even better sign when he rubs his cheek against Major M.'s cheek. And when an Afghan soldier feels truly at ease with Major M., he could very well take his hand and stroll through the camp with him, holding hands. This is the custom in Afghanistan...

True dat.

One of the smart things I think I did in my job was I aggressively sought out my British and American counterparts in other ANA brigades and corps and constantly compared notes with them. I found it gave me real advantages, perspective- and idea-sharing wise. We simply haven't yet got near enough best-practice info flowing within the mentoring "community."

2) Italians:

Strangest. Caveat. Ever.

From the AFP:

The leaders will also discuss the possibility of sending Italian soldiers into action immediately at the request of those leading operations.

Currently, Italian troops require six hours notice and America has repeatedly asked for this to be changed...

Hey, man, you try and get through the mandatory Verdi opera before every operation in less than six hours and see how you make out. Just getting the costumes on takes forever, then there's the lighting, the props... could put the British successes in North Africa in a new light, though.

Update: More on Germans:
German soldiers 'drink and complain too much to fight Taleban'
Earlier post:
Afstan: Germany flunking

2 Comments:

Blogger Positroll said...

The Spiegel article, while ok as such, really made me angry in one spot:

"A smart military campaign begins with thinking about how it will end, and with the question of how best to get out."
A smart campaign begins with thinking about how you WIN the war. The basic problem with our (i.e. the German gov) is that it does not want to admit that there is a war on. Perfect way to loose, if one side makes war and you play by peacetime rules ...

5:18 p.m., June 16, 2009  
Blogger Dave in Pa. said...

Regarding the Italians and their proclivities ...

Did you know that all the ships of the new Italian Navy have large portholes in their bottoms? That's so they can see the ships of the old Italian Navy. (OK, old joke, but it is kinda funny. :-)

9:53 a.m., June 17, 2009  

Post a Comment

<< Home