Friday, June 22, 2007

On staying in your lane

I've mentioned previously that the media swirl on the Gator story is overblown. Turns out I'm not the only one who thinks so.

Update: And note just how enthusiastic they are about the decision to suspend use of the Gators outside the wire.

Upperdate: Bruce Rolston throws more fuel on the pyre of flaming journalistic credibility:

The M-Gator, used by the Canadian, U.S. and other militaries, has a ground pressure when fully loaded of 8 psi. Human-foot ground pressure is 9-12 psi. So assuming the IED that destroyed the Gator was detonated by a pressure plate or other independent trigger, it likely would have been tripped by personnel walking from point A to B as well. And if it was command-detonated (ie, someone pressed a button to blow it up) it would also have been equally effective against three dismounted troops.

The general in charge has said the vehicle in question was used in part because of the narrowness of the local laneways, which would seem to rule out the use of any larger, better protected vehicle, regardless of their availability. So there may not have been a lot of good choices here, and given those ground pressure figures it at least seems unlikely the personnel would have been any safer walking that day.


Bruce is far more polite than I am. I'm inclined to send these poseurs in the press a personalized, gift-wrapped box of SHUT THE HELL UP.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

must be nice to be a journalist . . . an expert in everything except the truth, possessing an exceptional ability to spin a story to push negatives and create doubt.

All in the name of "journalism" . . . aka selling advertising space.


I have yet to read anything form any journalist about how frequently this vehicle was used for this mission - I'd bet it is a routine plt level supply run and probably used Gators many times in the past.

IF that is the case, IF any journalist with any cred has investigated that possibility then it should be reported.

Until they get the whole story, everything else is speculation, not reporting.

12:47 p.m., June 22, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home