Monday, April 09, 2007

Vimy Remembered and Rededicated

"It was Canada from the Atlantic to the Pacific on parade. In those few minutes I witnessed the birth of a nation." - B.Gen A.E. Ross

AT DAWN ON EASTER MONDAY, April 9, 1917, the greatest artillery barrage in military history opened up on Vimy Ridge. In the space of an hour and forty minutes, six million shells - three thousand per second - were thrown onto German positions atop the muddy scarp. "The wall of sound, like ten thousand thunders, drowned out men's voices and smothered the skirl of pipes...as if a hundred express trains were roaring overhead...tons of red-hot metal hurtling through the skies caused an artificial wind to spring up, intensifying the growing sleet storm slanting into the faces of the enemy. The earth reverberated for miles around, as in an earthquake, and the faint booming of the guns was heard by David Lloyd George, the British Prime Minister, at Downing Street in London." - Pierre Berton, Vimy.

With the ferocious Canadian Corps advancing up the ridge under a daring, rolling forward tactic called the creeping barrage, and taking almost the whole of its objective by mid-afternoon, the Imperial British and Canadian Expeditionary Forces finally won their first major sustained victory of the Great War. The Germans having strengthened the fortress for two years believed it to be impregnable. "The great whaleback of Vimy Ridge angled off into the gloom - it's hump as high as a fifty-storey building - a miniature Gibraltar, honeycombed with German tunnels and dugouts, a labyrnth of steel and concrete fortifications, bristling with guns of every calibre". Between 1914 and 1916, the French hurled 20 divisions against the ridge in three separate failed attacks, squandering 150,000 men. The Canadians took it with four divisions, and suffered 10,000 casualties - by the standards of the day, a stunning success. It is said that upon learning of the victory, a French soldier exclaimed, "C'est impossible!", and upon learning it was the Canadians who had won it, replied "Ah! les Canadiens! C'est possible!".


Generals Arthur Currie and Julian Byng. Byng was the Commander of the Canadian Corps at Vimy. He would be later raised to the peerage, becoming 1st Viscount Byng of Vimy, and later still, the Governor General of Canada. Currie, who would succeed him as Corps Commander, was responsible as Chief of Staff for the planning and execution of what became one of the most perfectly orchestrated attacks in the First World War. He would be ostensibly remembered as probably the finest military commander Canada has ever produced.

Arthur Currie knighted on the Vimy battlefield by King George V

Victoria Cross Recipients at Vimy
Clockwise from top left: Frederick Maurice Watson Harvey, Robert Grierson Combe, Ellis Wellwood Sifton, John George Pattison, William Johnstone Milne and Thain Wendell MacDowell.




Sir Robert Borden, Prime Minister of Canada
Canadian Prime Ministers since Confederation had always sought to make Canada an autonomous country within the British Empire. All that changed 90 years ago at the Battle of Vimy Ridge. Gaining a reputation as the "Shock Army of the British Empire" in the latter part of the Great War, the spearheaded victories of the battle-hardened Canadian Corps at Vimy, Passchendaele, Amiens and the Hundred Days forged the awakening of a nation, and stirred Sir Robert Borden to insist that Canada sign the Treaty of Versailles as a separate signatory over the objections of, ironically, not Great Britain, but the United States.

Walter Allward, Vimy's Winning Designer, Architect and Sculptor

King Edward VIII unveils the Vimy Memorial in 1936
Vimy became a symbol of sacrifice for the young Dominion. In 1922, the French government ceded to Canada in perpetuity Vimy Ridge, and the land surrounding it. The gleaming white marble and haunting sculptures of the Vimy Memorial, unveiled in 1936 by King Edward VIII (one of his few public acts as King before abdicating), stand as a terrible and poignant reminder of the more than sixty thousand Canadians who died serving their country during the First World War.

Adolf Hitler decides not to destroy the Vimy Memorial
Adolf Hitler visits Vimy in June 1940 as German Panzer divisions sweep through France. Hitler does not destroy the memorial as asserted in Canadian propoganda media reports. This is probably because the Vimy Memorial is not a monument to victory, but a mourning to sacrifice.


Mother Canada mourns over her dead at Vimy
Canada's most impressive tribute overseas to those Canadians who fought and gave their lives in the First World War is the majestic and inspiring Canadian National Vimy Memorial which overlooks the Douai Plain from the highest point of Vimy Ridge, about eight kilometres northeast of Arras. The Memorial does more than mark the site of the engagement that Canadians were to remember with more pride than any other operation of the First World War. It stands as a tribute to all who served their country in battle in that four-year struggle and particularly to those who gave their lives. At the base of the Memorial, these words appear in French and in English:

To the valour of their
Countrymen in the Great War
And in memory of their sixty
Thousand dead this monument
Is raised by the people of Canada


Inscribed on the ramparts of the Memorial are the names of 11,285 Canadian soldiers who were posted as "missing, presumed dead" in France.

POSTED BY THE MONARCHIST

Brooks' Update: If a picture is worth a thousand words, then the photos posted at Mitchieville tell quite the story of Vimy Ridge.

2 Comments:

Blogger Unknown said...

Outstanding blog Excellent work
I invite you to have a look at my blog

http://thetrenchline.blogspot.com/

Dutchknight

2:03 a.m., April 10, 2007  
Blogger STAG said...

Advance practice runs which usually get the credit were mostly useless since virtually all the landmarks were obliterated by the creeping barrage. However, counter battery fire for a change worked, wire cutting arillery fire for a change worked, and we had the trememdous luck to charge in the middle of a snowstorm...and they can't shoot what they can't see! Communications as usual were cut off, and so the deployed units simply had to follow the plan.
In other words, we were damned lucky! Valour does not win battles (witness Baumont-Hamel) nor does good leadership (was there every any?) but good logistics, good arty, good attitude, good soldiering (teamwork), and knowledge of the whole plan from the top on down to the lowest mule skinner proved to work.
Somehow people seem to think that deconstructing a battle this way somehow lessens the worth of the participants...on the contrary, it enhances it, but it "may" lessen the legend. Sorry.
Did the "brass" learn anything from this? Well, they must have. They weren't stupid. But they were limited by time, resources, and powerful office politics. I would personally love to read more about what worked than about how "valiant the men were".

5:27 p.m., April 16, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home